I’m glad I didn’t tell you.
I didn’t tell you I love you. And I am glad. Because I don’t, I didn’t. And I wouldn’t want to be untruthful.
I don’t love you. I really thought I did for a while, and I hoped that you might one day, too. But I didn’t and you didn’t, and I am glad I know that now. I realized this when I thought about the other people I loved–truly loved, two in particular–and remembered what real love really feels like. I thought about what I do, or rather did, for them, what I would do for them. I thought about how much it hurt to do those things sometimes; the sacrifice, the commitment, the loyalty. The love–there is no better word. I also thought about how much they loved me back, and how I never questioned that. Because they showed me. And I realized how important that is, to have someone love you back. To know it and to feel it. Without that, it is nearly impossible to love someone. Why else would you, unless they loved you too? You owe it to them if they do, because they would do nothing less for you. And that is the only way to be grateful for the love they give you, to give it right back. But without that, you don’t owe love to anyone. I thought about how much I loved these two people, and I realized what I feel for you doesn’t even come close.
Also, at that moment it occurred to me that you most likely don’t and haven’t ever truly loved someone. I cannot guarantee of course. I don’t know you, but the way you throw the word around, it sound like you don’t. This is so sad, because loving someone unconditionally is the single greatest gift I have ever been given and it has changed me for the better in ways I cannot ever fully explain. It has made me selfless and humble, and taught me that I am not the most important. It taught me what it means to be loyal and honor a bond with someone. It taught me that love is a choice, something you must actively and continually choose and prove through action and word. It taught me that it can hurt like hell. It taught me that there is nothing more fulfilling. It taught me that no one is owed love by title or position and no one is automatically granted love. It taught me that I am worthy of love. I dearly hope you get to truly love someone one day. I remember thinking and being so sure I loved people when I really didn’t and how unsatisfying that felt. I hope you will figure it out one day, because everyone should love and be loved. You deserve to be loved by someone, that someone just can’t be me, though.
Just because I don’t love you doesn’t mean I didn’t care. Because I did–a lot. You meant something to me and you will always mean something to me. I care about you more than you know. I gave you a lot of firsts. I really hope you don’t take that for granted, because it was a big deal to me. I know it wasn’t to you, but it was to me. I don’t regret that though. I don’t regret any of it, because I learned from it. That is what I will take away: a lot of “lessons learned”. I made a lot of mistakes, I know. I’m really sorry. I didn’t include you, I didn’t tell you what I was really thinking. I made a lot of decisions in my mind without you. I expected too much. I wasted a lot of time. I thought of you as I wanted you to be, not as you really were. For all of this, I am sorry.
I never trusted you. It took me a long time to figure out that I didn’t, but I never really did. I figured out that I didn’t, when I figured out why: You never gave me any reason to. I finally figured out that not once did you ever let yourself be vulnerable, you didn’t trust me. You said you did, but never acted on it, which makes me feel deceived. You would never let me hurt you, and you never trusted that I wouldn’t even if I could. I never felt like you cared. You were incredibly kind and generous and considerate, you told me how much you liked me. You enjoyed my company and you gave me time and effort, but you never gave me emotion. You had a heart of stone and I was never given the chance to know who you truly are, flaws and all. I knew what you thought about me, but I never knew what you felt, which leads me to believe that you didn’t at all. All of those good things lead me to believe that I trusted you, because I wanted to, but I realize now that I didn’t.
I also recently realized you were the first person to break my heart. I have cared before and liked before, but I have never given my heart before, which for some reason is something entirely different. I didn’t, I couldn’t, I wouldn’t, or you didn’t let me, give you all of it, but I did give you a piece of my heart. And that part is broken now. Mendable, but broken and it still hurts.
I don’t feel like I have any of yours, though, which is part of why I’m angry. The anger has faded somewhat, but it is certainly still there. But I am angry because it doesn’t seem like you are hurt, and that’s not fair. You screwed up. You are responsible. And I’m responsible too, but not like you are. And I am the one that is hurt. That just doesn’t seem fair. I want you to hurt too, to make it fair. I want you to see me happy, without you. I want you to see that I am fine. Because I am. And that is what you do to me—make me see you happy, without me. So that would make it fair. And it would show me that you did care, that you could hurt, that it meant anything to you at all.
I have tried not to be, but I am still really angry. Because you were stupid, and you broke my heart. You were so stupid it is not even funny. It was one of the biggest lapses in judgment I have ever seen. But you know what, in whatever strange universe, you still had noble intentions. You tried to do the right thing (you failed miserably), but you tried. And you know what sucks about that, is that as idiotic as you were, I can’t hate you for it, because you tried. And that just makes me more angry, because I want to hate you. That would be so much easier, if you were just a horrible person, but you’re not, so I can’t.
And it makes me angry that that was what you thought was the right thing to do. That really worries me, if that is how you think. What you did was so selfish and immature. You don’t mean to be, but you are. I thought you were better than that, I want you to be better than that. That was absolutely not the time or place. And, yes at some point those things needed to be said, in a far more tactful form. But not that day. I was still lost and vulnerable and destroyed. That was not you being noble, that was you being selfish. That day, that one day was about me, about me and no one else. I had earned that. And you made it about you. Which makes me more angry than I can explain. I am trying to forgive you for that, I know I need to for my sake, but I could never forget, that is not something you can forget. I should miss her, I should be thinking about her. But instead I am thinking about you. And I feel horribly guilty for that, because what kind of person does that make me, to be thinking of you, instead of her.
But I do. I still think about you. All the time. I miss you. I miss the idea of you. I miss all that I’d hoped we would be. I miss how I thought I was special to you. I miss the hope. I miss the fluttery feeling in the pit of my stomach when I thought you. I miss being nervous around you. I miss the chase. I miss blind, stubborn, hopeless infatuation. I miss the thought that missing you would be fun in some twisted way, because I would have had something real to miss. I miss the idea of it being real. I miss everything I thought you were. I miss believing I would know you. I miss your praise. I miss the way I used to feel. I miss having fun. I miss your lips, even though I know you won’t be able to focus after I say that. I miss pretending like I wasn’t really angry when you would do that.
Besides all of that, it hurts the most to know that what I want, I will never get to have. We are two totally different people. I had always said I saw so much of myself a year ago in you, based on everything you told me. It took me a long time to figure out that really, I see myself 3 years ago in you. Because of what you said, and how in reality none of it matched what you did. That is not meant to be a slam in any way, because that was me, too. I also don’t mean to sound like I know it all. I don’t, I know I don’t. But you think you do, at least a little bit, and that’s the problem: you don’t have a clue. I am confident enough in myself to say that I am wiser that you and you have a long way to go, but I believe in you. I am wise because I have suffered. Be glad you are not, the suffering I have endured, there are not words. I would not wish that kind of pain upon even my worst enemy. But it was valuable, because I learned from it, in large part because all of the far wiser people that came before me. I am disappointed that I couldn’t be that for you—someone to help you grow. I wanted to be. That is where the problem came in–you didn’t want that, certainly not from me and maybe not at all. You weren’t ready for that.
You said you knew me. That really bothered me. Because I know what I told you, or rather how much I hadn’t, and how much I still wanted to tell you. And for you to say you knew me based off of just that, for you to think that was it, with all of those crucial holes you could only know if I had told you, missing, for you to believe that was all there was to know, shows me that you don’t know me at all. You don’t know me, or how I think or why I do what I do. You also said she and I are the same person. And we are not. Not even close. And if you don’t think there is a difference, then that is even more of a problem. You don’t understand me, you didn’t give me that chance—to let you understand—so don’t pretend you do.
This is why we are different people. I am sure of what I believe. One thing I firmly believe is that all relationships have value, no matter the outcome, as long as you learn something. And that the point any and all relationships is to help the other person grow in some way, and in doing so you will hopefully grow and become better yourself. To do this you have to connect with people on a deeper level and you have to know yourself. You don’t believe this. You don’t spend hours discussing philosophy and morality and politics and religions and sociology. Which is fine, that doesn’t make you better or worse. (And certainly doesn’t make you good or bad because no one is good or bad, because people are more complicated than that and cannot be described so definitively or simply). But I do spend hours doing that, and that is important to me. To discuss things, to argue and disagree and poke holes in theories and research and ask opinions is important to me. Because being sure of what you believe in, and standing by that, no matter what it is, is important to me. And it isn’t to you. You aren’t sure of what you believe yet, which is fair, but you don’t actively try to discover it, whatever it may be.
You are not decisive, you are obedient. You do not love yourself. You think your dad doesn’t accept you. It matters to you that he does, more than it matters to you that you stand behind who you are and what you believe. You like to text. You don’t have a filter. You said I had bad taste in music because you never gave me the chance to tell you the story behind each song that I spent days hand selecting for you because they meant something to me, whether they were Katy Perry or not. There is a 50% chance you never cared about me at all. There is a 60% chance you think I am crazy for writing this. You talked shit about me behind my back. She told me that she wouldn’t say because she promised, (I know what loyalty and honoring her word, deserved or not means to her.) But she wouldn’t tell me because, if it were her, she wouldn’t want to know. You have no clue how much that hurt, because I wouldn’t do that to you. I may think it when I am angry, but I would never say it. All these are not simple nuisances, or differences to overcome, as I once believed, they are huge. They indicate such defining qualities of your character. So it would just never work. We are, on that level, so fundamentally different, we could never survive.
I am disappointed that you are not who I though you were. It’s frustrating that you can’t be. It hurts to realize how much I wanted that. I still care about you anyways, and I always will, even if you never did. I am not sure if I have forgiven you yet, but I’m trying. I’m still angry and hurt though. I know you try, but it isn’t enough. I’m glad it happened. Goodbye.